People and Politics in America's Big Cities
The Challenges to Urban Democracy
The changing face of America is creating new challenges and opportunities for America's urban centers.
According to a report released today, the emergence of new immigrant minority groups has transformed the competition for political power in large cities from one that pits native minorities against whites to one that pits new immigrants not only against whites, but also against native minority groups. It further finds that the simultaneous growing disparity between the racial and ethnic composition of the public and the composition of the elected has resulted in an increasing 'representation gap' between elected officials and those they represent.
Executive Summary
The conclusion of the Drum Major Institute’s “People and Politics in America’s Big Cities,” released in May of 2003, was clear: urban democracy is at the crossroads. Significant demographic changes have complicated our electoral landscape. In addition to suburbanization and internal migration, massive immigration has burred older racial and ethnic boundary lines. The result is a growing gap between the racial and ethnic backgrounds of those who govern and those who are governed by them. Experience has shown that if we fail to confront the nature of this “representation gap” in our cities or take steps to close it, we pay a heavy price.
The report, People and Politics in America's Big Cities:
The Challenges to Urban Democracy, was written by urban politics
experts John Mollenkopf, director of the CUNY Center for Urban
Research, and John Logan, director of the Lewis Mumford Center for
Comparative Urban and Regional Research. It was commissioned for a
conference sponsored by the Drum Major Institute for Public Policy with
The Century Foundation, Metropolitan College of New York, the CUNY
Center for Urban Research, and the Lewis Mumford Center for Comparative
Urban and Regional Research.
People and Politics in America's Big Cities uses New York and Los
Angeles as case studies for a critical investigation into the impact
the great changes underway in our nation's largest cities are having on
our politics and public policy. Together, New York and Los Angeles are
home to two-fifths of the immigrants in America. The study traces
political succession in these cities as they have changed from black
and white to multiethnic communities. It analyzes the 2001 mayoral and
city council elections in these cities to determine the political
consequences of these demographic changes and to draw conclusions about
significance of the 'representation gap' for the function of urban
democracy and the future of these cities.
The report is replete with tables and maps that provide racial,
ethnic, and socioeconomic data for New York neighborhoods. It also
provides information about voting patterns of various racial and ethnic
groups in New York and Los Angeles. Specific findings of the study
include:
- Latinos and Asians are increasingly prominent in cities where
racial diversity used to be understood in terms of black and white.
This is not only having an impact on political competition but also on
governance, service delivery, and, potentially, the image and economic
fortunes of cities.
- Whites hold political office in both cities at far higher rates
than their populations share and African Americans hold offices at
about parity with their population or a little more. However, Latinos
and Asians hold much less representation than their population share.
- There is a 20-year 'representation gap' for Latinos and Asians in
New York and Los Angeles. The current level of representation of these
groups matches their much smaller population share twenty years ago.
- While New York and Los Angeles are diverse cities, segregation
levels between whites and blacks, Latinos and Asians are significantly
above the national average, especially in New York.
- The increased diversity in the two cities led by new immigrant
groups has complicated the process of constructing multi-ethnic
coalitions seeking minority empowerment. They also have introduced
challenges for white incumbents, who must seek new ways to construct a
political majority.
- The 2001 elections in both cities revealed strain in the
multi-racial coalitions among blacks, Latinos and liberal whites that
had previously elected black mayors in New York and Los Angeles
John Mollenkopf and John Logan do not conclude that there is an
inevitable path for racial and ethnic succession in the two cities.
Rather they believe that by examining past patterns, New York and Los
Angeles may provide helpful lessons about how to manage demographic
change in ways that are politically inclusive and produce the best
climate for democracy and prosperity in large urban cities. The authors
conclude, for example, that by looking at the factors that cause the
'representation gap' in diverse cities — the characteristics of the
operation of the electoral systems, potential conflict and competition
among native and immigrant minority groups, and the larger patterns of
racial inequality in urban political systems — conversations can take
place and steps can be taken to improve the democratic process and to
create over time, a new, multi-ethnic, better-functioning urban
democracy.
The conference, based on this report, was designed
to begin that dialogue. The conference brought together political
strategists, community activists, labor and business leaders, academic
experts, and others to discuss the study's findings and implications
and to begin to strategize about how best to meet the political and
governance challenges of a changing city.
The conference featured a presentation by John Mollenkopf and John
Logan of the findings of their report. Featured speakers included
Dennis Archer, president-elect of the American Bar Association and
former mayor of Detroit, Fernando Ferrer, president of the Drum Major
Institute and former Bronx Borough President, Antonio Villaragosa,
member of the Los Angeles City Council, and Pete Hamill, author and
journalist. Panel participants included: Margaret Fung, Asian American
Legal Defense and Education Fund; Tamar Jacoby, Manhattan Institute;
Robert George, New York Post; Roberto Ramirez, the Mirram Group; Hank
Sheinkopf, Sheinkopf Communications; David Axelrod, Axelrod and
Associates; Xavier Briggs, Harvard University; and Wilbur Rich,
Wellesley College. Jonathan Hicks, a metro political reporter for the
New York Times served as moderator for both panels.
Testimonials
Produced by John Logan and John Mollenkopf, it “People and Politics in America’s Big Cities” details the vast impact of immigration and the extraordinary transformation of New York City's whites from a majority of the population to a minority. It looks at the sparring for political primacy that will arise from this change - as whites are forced to share power not just with blacks but with Latinos and Asians and countless other newcomers.Joseph Dolman
, Newsday
This discussion has had a big impact on California, where the rising Latin population has
inspired a good amount of dread, perhaps because the increasing numbers may result in ethnic blocs that are no more interested in sharing power than whites were when they held all the cards.
As the various speakers acknowledged, we have to embrace our collective humanity and build coalitions around issues, not categories. We have to see where we're going, and we have to make sure all of us go there - and that there is no segregated seating.
Stanley Crouch
, New York Daily News
El estudio seÒala adem·s que a pesar de que Los ¡ngeles y Nueva York son ciudades muy diversas, los niveles de segregaci—n entre blancos, afroamericanos, latinos y asi·ticos, son m·s altos que en el resto del pa“s, especialmente en Nueva York.Mariana Reyes Angler—
, holaHoy.com
Una nueva pugna no exclusivamente Ètnica toma cuerpo en las grandes ciudades como consecuencia de las nuevas olas migratorias, que suma a la cl·sica confrontaci—n entre la poblaci—n de raza blanca y las minor“as Ètnicas, el choque entre nuevos grupos inmigrantes versus las comunidades Ètnicas originarias.Enrique Soria
, el diario